A Presumption of Equality

Andrew Harrop

Online

This report looks at mid-income older people, a group who have been overlooked in political and media debates about later life. Perspectives on ageing are dominated by how people think about the ‘top’ and the ‘bottom’. There are two competing narratives of later life: wealthy baby-boomers versus pensioners on the breadline facing poverty, isolation and ill-health. The truth is that the majority of older people today are somewhere in between – neither rich nor poor – and the middle is expanding as a result of recent successes in reducing pensioner poverty.

This report argues that government should adopt a ‘presumption of equality’ when considering public policy for different age groups. There is a legitimate worry that older people have not been sharing sufficiently in the pain of current deficit reduction. All policies which appear to give special advantages to older people as a category should be reviewed, because in financial terms alone, older people are no longer special. That does not mean scrapping all age-based variations, and this report demonstrates the vital place of a strong state pension system for middle income groups. But it does mean assessing the evidence and rationale for existing rules on social security, taxation and the design of services.

With this in mind there may be a case for cutting some public spending: means-testing the winter fuel payment is one ‘least bad’ option, though the savings would be comparatively modest. But there is a much stronger case for increasing taxes on older people to bring them into line with other households, with serious consideration paid to the gradual integration of national insurance and income, as part of a ‘grand bargain’ with the extra revenue earmarked for social care and the NHS.